Incident Report: Synthesis of Reported Safety-Critical Events in the Lucid Air
1.0 Introduction
This report provides a formal, objective synthesis of customer-reported safety complaints concerning the Lucid Air vehicle, based on an analysis of the provided source context. The scope of this analysis is strictly limited to the incidents and descriptions detailed within the supplied source material. The methodology involves categorizing reported incidents into thematic groups based on system function and potential risk. This structured approach is designed to inform a subsequent engineering review and a comprehensive risk assessment of the identified failure patterns. The analysis begins with the most severe category of reported events: failures related to the vehicle's core propulsion system.
Get complete access to this detailed incident analysis
Get complete access to this detailed incident analysis
Get complete access to this detailed incident analysis
This report provides a formal, objective synthesis of customer-reported safety complaints concerning the Lucid Air vehicle, based on an analysis of the provided source context. The scope of this analysis is strictly limited to the incidents and descriptions detailed within the supplied source material. The methodology involves categorizing reported incidents into thematic groups based on system function and potential risk. This structured approach is designed to inform a subsequent engineering review and a comprehensive risk assessment of the identified failure patterns. The analysis begins with the most severe category of reported events: failures related to the vehicle's core propulsion system.
2.0 Category 1: Critical Propulsion System and Drivetrain Failures
A rigorous analysis of propulsion system failures is strategically paramount. A sudden, complete loss of motive power, particularly when occurring at highway speeds, represents one of the most severe safety risks a driver can face. These incidents suggest potential systemic faults within the high-voltage battery contactors, inverter logic, or the drivetrain control unit itself. Such events can lead to a rapid loss of vehicle control and create a high probability of collision with surrounding traffic, which may be unprepared for the vehicle's abrupt deceleration. The complaints reviewed contain multiple instances of this high-risk failure mode.
2.1 Sudden and Total Loss of Motive Power
A recurring theme in the complaint data is the sudden and often total loss of the vehicle's ability to accelerate or maintain speed. These events were frequently reported as occurring without warning and at high speeds, forcing drivers to perform emergency maneuvers in live traffic.
2.2 Directional Control Failures
Compounding the propulsion system concerns are reports of fundamental directional control failures, where the vehicle's movement is contrary to the selected gear. This presents a severe collision risk, particularly during low-speed maneuvers in confined spaces such as garages, parking lots, or near charging infrastructure, where driver expectation of vehicle direction is absolute. Complainants describe incidents where the "Vehicle sometimes drives in the OPPOSITE direction of selected Gear" (Complaint ID: 1848529). Another complainant reported a situation where, regardless of the selected gear, the vehicle only moved in one direction: "...no matter what it moves only FORWARD direction." (Complaint IDs: 1955356, 1955355). A further report details that "...with the shifter set to reverse, pressing on the accelerator resulted in the car lurching forward" (Complaint IDs: 1911044, 1911045). These events point to a critical logic failure in the drivetrain control module.
These patterns of propulsion loss and directional confusion are followed by another serious category of failures involving erratic and uncommanded vehicle control events.
3.0 Category 2: Anomalous Vehicle Control Events
Unintended vehicle control events have critical safety implications. These reports suggest potential flaws in the sensor fusion, throttle mapping, or brake-by-wire control logic. Any instance of unpredictable acceleration or braking erodes driver confidence and can directly cause collisions by overriding driver input at a critical moment. The data reveals distinct patterns of both uncommanded acceleration and unexpected braking, indicating potential systemic issues within the vehicle's speed control logic.
3.1 Unintended Acceleration
Multiple reports describe the vehicle accelerating without or contrary to driver input. These incidents occurred in various contexts, from being stopped in traffic to maneuvering at low speeds, each presenting a unique and significant hazard.
3.2 Erratic and Uncommanded Braking
Equally hazardous are reports of the vehicle braking suddenly and without justification. These events create a significant risk of a rear-end collision, as highlighted by one complainant who stated, "The first time happened on the interstate and the vehicle behind me had to go into the median to keep from rear ending me." (Complaint ID: 1918716). Another report documents the car braking "violently" while backing up in a driveway, suggesting a potential sensor or software malfunction in the collision avoidance system (Complaint IDs: 1876054, 1876056, 1876055).
The analysis now shifts from primary vehicle movement to the auxiliary safety systems designed to support the driver.
4.0 Category 3: Malfunctions in Driver-Assist and Core Safety Systems
While not always causing an immediate loss of control, failures in modern safety and driver-assist systems (ADAS) create significant latent risk. These reports point to potential deficiencies in the Advanced Driver-Assistance Systems (ADAS) perception stack, Body Control Module (BCM) software, or the integrity of CAN bus communications. Drivers come to rely on these features for situational awareness and accident prevention, and their unexpected failure can lead to dangerous outcomes, particularly when the system's behavior contradicts its intended function.
4.1 Forward Collision Avoidance and Cruise Control Deficiencies
A critical failure was reported in the vehicle's adaptive cruise control system. According to the complaint, the system "does not slow for stopped highway traffic" and "will continue to speed...right into the rear end of stopped vehicles" unless manually overridden by the driver (Complaint ID: 1887057). This represents a fundamental flaw in a core ADAS feature and poses an extreme risk of a high-speed rear-end collision.
4.2 Uncommanded Seat Movement
Multiple complaints document a severe physical hazard posed by uncontrolled and uncommanded seat adjustments while the vehicle is in use. One driver reported their seat moving to the "full forward...position without warning pinning my knees against the lower dash" and rendering manual controls inoperable (Complaint ID: 1854387). A similar event was described where the passenger seat "spontaneously started to move forward folding the passenger in half" (Complaint ID: 1904345). Such malfunctions represent a failure of the Body Control Module (BCM) or associated CAN bus messaging, creating an unacceptable risk of driver incapacitation and physical harm to occupants.
4.3 Ancillary System Failures
Other foundational safety systems have also been reported as malfunctioning, undermining the vehicle's overall safety profile.
Finally, the report examines issues related to the physical integrity of vehicle components.
5.0 Category 4: Component and Structural Integrity Issues
The issues cataloged in this section, while potentially less dynamic than software or system failures, point to potential gaps in manufacturing quality control. Such issues raise concerns regarding manufacturing processes, supplier component quality, and final assembly verification protocols. These failures can still pose safety risks, such as preventing occupant egress in an emergency, compromising vehicle stability, or leading to a loss of control.
Summary of Structural and Component Complaints
Component Category Reported Issue(s) Associated Complaint ID(s)
Doors & Latches Driver's side door fails to unlatch consistently; left rear passenger door opens when another door is opened. 1966871, 1978810
Body Structure Trunk fails to close properly, even after multiple repair attempts. 1978811
Tires & Wheels Reports of a tire blowout, a large bubble forming in a sidewall after a small bump, and incorrect tire sizes being installed on the rear wheels from the factory. 1931750, 1931749, 1999302, 2001157
6.0 Conclusion and Recommendation
This synthesis of customer complaints identifies several deeply concerning patterns of safety-critical failures in the Lucid Air vehicle. The analysis reveals three primary areas of high-risk malfunctions: 1) sudden and total loss of propulsion, often at highway speeds; 2) anomalous vehicle control events, including unintended acceleration and uncommanded braking; and 3) critical failures of core driver-assist systems, most notably an adaptive cruise control system reported to be incapable of recognizing stopped traffic. These issues, individually and collectively, represent a significant risk to vehicle occupants and the public.
It is formally recommended that this report be escalated for an immediate and comprehensive engineering and risk assessment review. The review should prioritize a root-cause analysis of the propulsion, vehicle control, and ADAS software and hardware systems to identify and rectify the sources of these reported safety failures.